Company Phone Number 24/7 Claim Service
1st Choice Auto 1-888-717-8090 Yes
Aegis 1-800-233-2160 Yes
American Modern 1-800-375-2075 Yes
Atlantic States/Donegal 1-800-877-9006 Yes
CNA Surety 1-800-331-6053  
Conemaugh Valley Mutual 814-266-8737
Between 9am - 5pm. After 5 call
Castle Claims direct
@ 412-343-3223
Yes
Countryway 1-800-828-6862
(Between 8:00 am & 4:30 pm)
1-888-223-3649
(After 4:30 pm)
Yes
Donegal/Atlantic States 1-800-877-9006 Yes
Donegal Glass Windshield Claims 1-866-439-4527 Yes
Everett Cash Mutual 1-888-717-8090  
Fair Plan 1-800-462-4972  
Farmers Mutual 1-800-545-7806  
Foremost Insurance 1-800-527-3907 Yes
Infinity/Classic Collectors 1-800-252-5233 Yes
GMAC 1-800-468-3466 yes
Millville Mutual 1-800-262-8495
After hours press option 5
Yes
Motorists Mutual 1-800-876-8766 Yes
Northland 1-800-328-5972 Yes
National Flood 1-800-759-8656 Yes
Patrons Call Farmers Mutual
1-800-545-7806
 
Pennsylvania Workers Comp. 570-963-4621  
Progressive 1-800-776-4737 Yes
Rockwood Insurance 1-800-442-8063  
Travelers 1-800-252-4633 Yes
Volunteer Fire Departments 1-800-233-1957 Yes


© Copyright 2007 Buff Insurance Agency | Designed by Doug Keeling | June 2007